Response to Comment on "Forest microclimate dynamics drive plant responses to warming"

Florian Zellweger; Pieter De Frenne; Jonathan Lenoir; Pieter Vangansbeke; Kris Verheyen; Markus Bernhardt-Römermann; Lander Baeten; Radim Hédl; Imre Berki; Jörg Brunet; Hans Van Calster; Markéta Chudomelová; Guillaume Decocq; Thomas Dirnböck; Tomasz Durak; Thilo Heinken; Bogdan Jaroszewicz; Martin Kopecký; Frantiv sek Máliv s; Martin Macek; Marek Malicki; Tobias Naaf; Thomas A. Nagel; Adrienne Ortmann-Ajkai; Petr Petv rik; Remigiusz Pielech; Kamila Reczyska; Wolfgang Schmidt; Tibor Standovár; Krzysztof wierkosz; Balázs Teleki; Ondv rej Vild; Monika Wulf; David Coomes

doi:10.1126/science.abd6193

Response to Comment on "Forest microclimate dynamics drive plant responses to warming"

Florian Zellweger, Pieter De Frenne, Jonathan Lenoir, Pieter Vangansbeke, Kris Verheyen, Markus Bernhardt-Römermann, Lander Baeten, Radim Hédl, Imre Berki, Jörg Brunet, Hans Van Calster, Markéta Chudomelová, Guillaume Decocq, Thomas Dirnböck, Tomasz Durak, Thilo Heinken, Bogdan Jaroszewicz, Martin Kopecký, Frantiv sek Máliv s, Martin MacekMarek Malicki, Tobias Naaf, Thomas A. Nagel, Adrienne Ortmann-Ajkai, Petr Petv rik, Remigiusz Pielech, Kamila Reczyska, Wolfgang Schmidt, Tibor Standovár, Krzysztof wierkosz, Balázs Teleki, Ondv rej Vild, Monika Wulf, David Coomes

Biometry, Methodology and Quality Assurance

Research output: Contribution to journal › A1: Web of Science-article › peer-review

893 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Bertrand et al. question our interpretation about warming effects on the thermophilization in forest plant communities and propose an alternative way to analyze climatic debt. We show that microclimate warming is a better predictor than macroclimate warming for studying forest plant community responses to warming. Their additional analyses do not affect or change our interpretations and conclusions.

Original language	English
Journal	Science (Washington)
Volume	370
Issue number	6520
ISSN	0036-8075
DOIs	https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abd6193
Publication status	Published - 27-Nov-2020

Thematic List 2020

Forest
Climate

Thematic list

Forest management
Climate

Access to Document

10.1126/science.abd6193

Zellweger_etal_2020_Science_ResponseFinal published version, 314 KBLicence: CC BY

Cite this

Zellweger, F., De Frenne, P., Lenoir, J., Vangansbeke, P., Verheyen, K., Bernhardt-Römermann, M., Baeten, L., Hédl, R., Berki, I., Brunet, J., Van Calster, H., Chudomelová, M., Decocq, G., Dirnböck, T., Durak, T., Heinken, T., Jaroszewicz, B., Kopecký, M., Máliv s, F. S., ... Coomes, D. (2020). Response to Comment on "Forest microclimate dynamics drive plant responses to warming". Science (Washington), 370(6520). https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abd6193

Zellweger, Florian ; De Frenne, Pieter ; Lenoir, Jonathan ; Vangansbeke, Pieter ; Verheyen, Kris ; Bernhardt-Römermann, Markus ; Baeten, Lander ; Hédl, Radim ; Berki, Imre ; Brunet, Jörg ; Van Calster, Hans ; Chudomelová, Markéta ; Decocq, Guillaume ; Dirnböck, Thomas ; Durak, Tomasz ; Heinken, Thilo ; Jaroszewicz, Bogdan ; Kopecký, Martin ; Máliv s, Frantiv sek ; Macek, Martin ; Malicki, Marek ; Naaf, Tobias ; Nagel, Thomas A. ; Ortmann-Ajkai, Adrienne ; Petv rik, Petr ; Pielech, Remigiusz ; Reczyska, Kamila ; Schmidt, Wolfgang ; Standovár, Tibor ; wierkosz, Krzysztof ; Teleki, Balázs ; Vild, Ondv rej ; Wulf, Monika ; Coomes, David. / Response to Comment on "Forest microclimate dynamics drive plant responses to warming". In: Science (Washington). 2020 ; Vol. 370, No. 6520.

@article{ec71fd77e8364dde89718482af96b309,

title = "Response to Comment on {"}Forest microclimate dynamics drive plant responses to warming{"}",

abstract = "Bertrand et al. question our interpretation about warming effects on the thermophilization in forest plant communities and propose an alternative way to analyze climatic debt. We show that microclimate warming is a better predictor than macroclimate warming for studying forest plant community responses to warming. Their additional analyses do not affect or change our interpretations and conclusions.",

author = "Florian Zellweger and {De Frenne}, Pieter and Jonathan Lenoir and Pieter Vangansbeke and Kris Verheyen and Markus Bernhardt-R{\"o}mermann and Lander Baeten and Radim H{\'e}dl and Imre Berki and J{\"o}rg Brunet and {Van Calster}, Hans and Mark{\'e}ta Chudomelov{\'a} and Guillaume Decocq and Thomas Dirnb{\"o}ck and Tomasz Durak and Thilo Heinken and Bogdan Jaroszewicz and Martin Kopeck{\'y} and {M{\'a}liv s}, {Frantiv sek} and Martin Macek and Marek Malicki and Tobias Naaf and Nagel, {Thomas A.} and Adrienne Ortmann-Ajkai and {Petv rik}, Petr and Remigiusz Pielech and Kamila Reczyska and Wolfgang Schmidt and Tibor Standov{\'a}r and Krzysztof wierkosz and Bal{\'a}zs Teleki and Vild, {Ondv rej} and Monika Wulf and David Coomes",

year = "2020",

month = nov,

day = "27",

doi = "10.1126/science.abd6193",

language = "English",

volume = "370",

journal = "Science (Washington)",

issn = "0036-8075",

publisher = "American Association for the Advancement of Science",

number = "6520",

}

Zellweger, F, De Frenne, P, Lenoir, J, Vangansbeke, P, Verheyen, K, Bernhardt-Römermann, M, Baeten, L, Hédl, R, Berki, I, Brunet, J, Van Calster, H, Chudomelová, M, Decocq, G, Dirnböck, T, Durak, T, Heinken, T, Jaroszewicz, B, Kopecký, M, Máliv s, FS, Macek, M, Malicki, M, Naaf, T, Nagel, TA, Ortmann-Ajkai, A, Petv rik, P, Pielech, R, Reczyska, K, Schmidt, W, Standovár, T, wierkosz, K, Teleki, B, Vild, OR, Wulf, M & Coomes, D 2020, 'Response to Comment on "Forest microclimate dynamics drive plant responses to warming"', Science (Washington), vol. 370, no. 6520. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abd6193

Response to Comment on "Forest microclimate dynamics drive plant responses to warming". / Zellweger, Florian; De Frenne, Pieter; Lenoir, Jonathan; Vangansbeke, Pieter; Verheyen, Kris; Bernhardt-Römermann, Markus; Baeten, Lander; Hédl, Radim; Berki, Imre; Brunet, Jörg; Van Calster, Hans; Chudomelová, Markéta; Decocq, Guillaume; Dirnböck, Thomas; Durak, Tomasz; Heinken, Thilo; Jaroszewicz, Bogdan; Kopecký, Martin; Máliv s, Frantiv sek; Macek, Martin; Malicki, Marek; Naaf, Tobias; Nagel, Thomas A.; Ortmann-Ajkai, Adrienne; Petv rik, Petr; Pielech, Remigiusz; Reczyska, Kamila; Schmidt, Wolfgang; Standovár, Tibor; wierkosz, Krzysztof; Teleki, Balázs; Vild, Ondv rej; Wulf, Monika; Coomes, David.

In: Science (Washington), Vol. 370, No. 6520, 27.11.2020.

Research output: Contribution to journal › A1: Web of Science-article › peer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Response to Comment on "Forest microclimate dynamics drive plant responses to warming"

AU - Zellweger, Florian

AU - De Frenne, Pieter

AU - Lenoir, Jonathan

AU - Vangansbeke, Pieter

AU - Verheyen, Kris

AU - Bernhardt-Römermann, Markus

AU - Baeten, Lander

AU - Hédl, Radim

AU - Berki, Imre

AU - Brunet, Jörg

AU - Van Calster, Hans

AU - Chudomelová, Markéta

AU - Decocq, Guillaume

AU - Dirnböck, Thomas

AU - Durak, Tomasz

AU - Heinken, Thilo

AU - Jaroszewicz, Bogdan

AU - Kopecký, Martin

AU - Máliv s, Frantiv sek

AU - Macek, Martin

AU - Malicki, Marek

AU - Naaf, Tobias

AU - Nagel, Thomas A.

AU - Ortmann-Ajkai, Adrienne

AU - Petv rik, Petr

AU - Pielech, Remigiusz

AU - Reczyska, Kamila

AU - Schmidt, Wolfgang

AU - Standovár, Tibor

AU - wierkosz, Krzysztof

AU - Teleki, Balázs

AU - Vild, Ondv rej

AU - Wulf, Monika

AU - Coomes, David

PY - 2020/11/27

Y1 - 2020/11/27

N2 - Bertrand et al. question our interpretation about warming effects on the thermophilization in forest plant communities and propose an alternative way to analyze climatic debt. We show that microclimate warming is a better predictor than macroclimate warming for studying forest plant community responses to warming. Their additional analyses do not affect or change our interpretations and conclusions.

AB - Bertrand et al. question our interpretation about warming effects on the thermophilization in forest plant communities and propose an alternative way to analyze climatic debt. We show that microclimate warming is a better predictor than macroclimate warming for studying forest plant community responses to warming. Their additional analyses do not affect or change our interpretations and conclusions.

U2 - 10.1126/science.abd6193

DO - 10.1126/science.abd6193

M3 - A1: Web of Science-article

VL - 370

JO - Science (Washington)

JF - Science (Washington)

SN - 0036-8075

IS - 6520

ER -